Rhymes with Rug Gilson
I’ve been privileged to serve alongside of Pastor Doug Wilson now for almost a decade. One of the distinguishing marks of his ministry that I’ve only grown in appreciation for is his adept skill of saying true things in sticky ways. Many Evangelicals will pass around dog-eared copies of Future Men, Her Hand in Marriage, or Standing on the Promises, expressing appreciation for the practical Christian teaching found in them. But they will hasten to add, “I don’t agree with everything he says, and sometimes when he’s being polemical he says some things I wish he wouldn’t.”
But I’d like point out that the same skill that makes his teaching on practical Christian living so memorable and helpful is employed in his attack on various unbiblical teachings or ungodly opponents. The serrated edge, as he calls it, should not be thought of as an asterisk on an otherwise helpful teaching ministry. Rather, it is the serrated edge which has made it possible for his teaching ministry on things like parenting, marriage, and community life to flourish. Barbed wire around the ranch keeps the coyotes out, after all.
The principle in play here is that it is not an abdication of Scripture’s command to love our enemies to speak to them in such a way as to jostle their sensibilities, offend their vanities, and jar them out of their living at ease with evil. Wielding language in such a way as to make your point memorable is, in fact, a duty of ministers. This should be the case in crafting sermons, in how you counsel a failing marriage, and how you engage the enemies of the Gospel. In the case of the last example, it is actually an expression of love to not fight such enemies with a dull blade.
Like Cocaine Bear
Doug and others have made the case for the serrated edge elsewhere. Heck, Doug even wrote a book about it, which I heartily recommend. When we engage with opponents we are to do so like Christ. But Christ is not confined to a few sweet sayings. All of Scripture is our guidebook in how we are to fight evil, rhetorically speaking. And once you see it, you cannot help but see that the Prophets, Christ Himself, and the Apostles all, at times, spoke with all the delicacy of that one Tennessee bear that ate some cocaine. While Scriptural instances are numerous, my aim here is not to list out all the spicy rhetoric of Ezekiel. My point here is to simply insist that our sense of decency and politeness is not what should guide our apologetics, evangelism, or cultural rebuke. Scripture must.
So then, it shouldn’t surprise us when a sharp rebuke is actually more effective than nuanced evasions. A gentle answer does indeed turn away wrath. But we should remember that God’s gentleness includes tearing and smiting in order to heal and soothe. When in the course of our battles with vain philosophies we add an extra blob of jalapeño mustard, it is not simply out of preference. It is a particular act of faith and obedience. We must trust that in speaking bluntly we are aiming at the salvation of the enemies of the cross. Even in our bluntness, we ought to endeavor to say things in such a way so as to make that bluntness sticky.
Of Course it’s a Dangerous Tool
Now, it is worth pointing out that this tactic has dangers. But we could just as easily point out that the winsomeness of TGC has resulted in some pretty appalling abdications of truth. When anon accounts are blasting some opponent with vindictive ad hominem attacks they may think they are emulating Doug in his use of the serrated edge. But the problem is that the anon army has failed to demonstrate that their aim is restorative. They seem to take delight in having fiddled with the dial that controls their rhetorical serrated edge and can turn it up to 11. But just because you figured out how to start the chainsaw does not mean you are a skilled lumberjack. You may equally be a villain in one of those hokey Halloween movies.
So then, the serrated edge is not for children. Insolence is not the same as skillfully wounding an opponent in order that he would feel the smart. But the wound is not the point. The point is so that they might perhaps seek out the healing found in the left hand of the one who wounded them. Being good at insults doesn’t make you a Gospel warrior for truth and charity. Trolling people on the internet is child’s play. Meme-ing the boomers is low-hanging fruit. If you want to develop the skill of addressing folly and immaturity head on, start with your toddlers. If you want to realize a Christian Nation, start with a Christian marriage. These things require patience. Diligent and sacrificial service for those in your home and church community is your starting point for defeating principalities and powers.

The Glory of Steak Knives
Think of the serrated edge like your steak knives. The goal is not to mangle the poor steak. The goal is to cut it into pieces that can be swallowed. If you’ve ever assigned your young son to unload the silverware, you’ve probably caught him swinging mom’s steak knives around like swords. His ambition shouldn’t be dampened, but your job as his father is to join it with self-control. Teach him the telos of steak knives.
Thus, as you think about your own interactions with opponents of the Gospel, you should aspire to use all the tools available to the saints, and to use them well. Including the glorious tool of the serrated edge, or to use a more biblical term: the prophetic voice. But this comes with the duty to humble yourself when you gauge out a bystander’s eye because you failed to join your zeal for truth with the restraint of Christian charity.
You must be logged in to post a comment.